Glossary
Three-tier system
Alcohol moves producer to wholesaler to retailer, each tier separately licensed. It is the post-Prohibition default that every DtC law cuts through.
After Prohibition ended in 1933, the 21st Amendment left alcohol regulation to the states, and nearly all of them built the same wall: producers sell to licensed wholesalers, wholesalers to licensed retailers, retailers to the public. Every DtC shipping law is an explicit, narrow exception cut through that wall.
The system explains the winery/retailer asymmetry on this site. Courts have forced states to treat out-of-state wine producers like in-state ones, but retailer shipping is still widely treated as an in-state privilege of the third tier.
Questions
- Why does the three-tier system still matter for shipping?
- Because a state that prohibits your shipment is not being obstinate; it is declining to create an exception to its core alcohol structure. Understanding that makes the map's patchwork legible.